Indianapolis Colts Single Season Punting Leaders

Ranked by Punting Gross Average

The following are the Indianapolis Colts single season punting leaders ranked by punting gross average. Included are player stats for the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) from 1984-2020, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) from 1953-1983, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) in 1950 and the Baltimore Colts (AAFC) from 1947-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Pat McAfee is the Indianapolis Colts single season leader in gross punting average with 49.3.

Players active with the Indianapolis Colts during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

Leaders based on 40 punts

      Punting
Player Season Team Num Yds Avg Lg TB In20 Blk Net
  P. McAfee 2016 Ind 55 2,711 49.3 74 9 19 1 42.7
  P. McAfee 2012 Ind 73 3,520 48.2 64 8 26 1 40.3
  P. McAfee 2015 Ind 85 4,052 47.7 63 6 28 0 41.7
  P. McAfee 2014 Ind 69 3,221 46.7 61 3 30 0 42.8
  P. McAfee 2011 Ind 88 4,098 46.6 64 3 21 1 39.2
  R. Sanchez 2018 Ind 57 2,629 46.1 63 5 24 0 42.7
  P. McAfee 2013 Ind 76 3,499 46.0 65 7 27 1 38.5
  R. Stark 1985 Ind 78 3,584 45.9 68 14 12 2 34.1
  C. Gardocki 1996 Ind 68 3,105 45.7 61 2 23 0 39.0
  D. Lee 1966 Bal 49 2,233 45.6 64 0 0 0 0.0
  C. Gardocki 1998 Ind 79 3,583 45.4 62 10 23 0 37.1
  R. Stark 1983 Bal 91 4,124 45.3 68 9 20 0 36.3
  C. Gardocki 1997 Ind 67 3,034 45.3 72 6 18 0 36.2
  D. Lee 1969 Bal 57 2,580 45.3 66 0 0 0 0.0
  H. Smith 2004 Ind 54 2,443 45.2 62 3 21 0 36.8
  R. Stark 1986 Ind 76 3,432 45.2 63 5 22 0 37.2
  R. Sanchez 2017 Ind 84 3,764 44.8 61 3 28 1 42.6
  R. Stark 1992 Ind 83 3,716 44.8 64 7 22 0 39.3
  D. Lee 1970 Bal 63 2,819 44.7 62 0 0 1 0.0
  R. Stark 1984 Ind 98 4,383 44.7 72 7 21 0 37.2
  H. Smith 2000 Ind 65 2,906 44.7 65 9 20 0 36.4
  H. Smith 2001 Ind 68 3,023 44.5 65 12 12 0 33.8
  R. Stark 1982 Bal 46 2,044 44.4 60 12 8 0 34.3
  R. Sanchez 2019 Ind 59 2,619 44.4 60 1 22 0 41.2
  H. Smith 2006 Ind 47 2,085 44.4 61 5 14 1 34.5
  P. McAfee 2009 Ind 64 2,837 44.3 60 6 21 0 37.8
  H. Smith 2005 Ind 52 2,301 44.2 58 5 23 0 37.1
  H. Smith 2008 Ind 53 2,343 44.2 64 2 23 0 38.8
  R. Stark 1988 Ind 64 2,784 43.5 65 8 15 0 34.5
  R. Stark 1990 Ind 71 3,084 43.4 61 3 24 1 37.4
  R. Stark 1993 Ind 83 3,595 43.3 65 13 18 0 35.9
  T. Gilburg 1961 Bal 42 1,804 43.0 61 0 0 0 0.0
  R. Stark 1989 Ind 79 3,392 42.9 64 10 14 1 32.9
  R. Stark 1991 Ind 82 3,492 42.6 65 6 14 0 34.8
  C. Gardocki 1995 Ind 63 2,681 42.6 69 7 16 0 33.4
  H. Smith 1999 Ind 58 2,467 42.5 61 8 16 2 30.6
  R. Stark 1994 Ind 73 3,092 42.4 60 10 22 1 34.1
  D. Lee 1967 Bal 49 2,075 42.3 68 0 0 0 0.0
  H. Smith 2003 Ind 62 2,617 42.2 55 3 20 1 35.5
  D. Lee 1972 Bal 57 2,400 42.1 60 0 0 1 0.0
  P. McAfee 2010 Ind 65 2,731 42.0 66 7 21 0 35.4
  D. Sherer 1959 Bal 51 2,140 42.0 60 0 0 0 0.0
  H. Smith 2007 Ind 52 2,181 41.9 63 5 18 0 34.2
  T. Gilburg 1962 Bal 57 2,384 41.8 62 0 0 0 0.0
  T. Gilburg 1963 Bal 52 2,173 41.8 64 0 0 0 0.0
  D. Lee 1971 Bal 62 2,542 41.0 76 0 0 0 0.0
  H. Smith 2002 Ind 66 2,672 40.5 69 9 26 1 34.9
  A. Burk 1950 Bal 81 3,243 40.0 68 0 0 1 0.0
  R. Stark 1987 Ind 61 2,440 40.0 63 7 12 2 30.9
  R. Brown 1958 Bal 41 1,635 39.9 60 0 0 0 0.0