Indianapolis Colts Single Season Scoring Leaders

Ranked by Extra Points Attempted

The following are the Indianapolis Colts single season scoring leaders ranked by extra points attempted. Included are player stats for the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) from 1984-2020, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) from 1953-1983, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) in 1950 and the Baltimore Colts (AAFC) from 1947-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Mike Vanderjagt is the Indianapolis Colts single season leader in extra points attempted with 60.

Players active with the Indianapolis Colts during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

      Field Goals Extra Points
Player Season Team FGM FGA FG Pct XPM XPA XP Pct
  M. Vanderjagt 2004 Ind 20 25 80.0 59 60 98.3
  L. Michaels 1964 Bal 17 35 48.6 53 54 98.1
  T. Linhart 1975 Bal 10 18 55.6 51 52 98.1
  M. Vanderjagt 2005 Ind 23 25 92.0 52 52 100.0
  S. Myhra 1958 Bal 4 10 40.0 48 51 94.1
  S. Myhra 1959 Bal 6 17 35.3 50 51 98.0
  A. Vinatieri 2010 Ind 26 28 92.9 51 51 100.0
  A. Vinatieri 2007 Ind 23 29 79.3 49 51 96.1
  T. Linhart 1976 Bal 20 27 74.1 49 50 98.0
  L. Michaels 1968 Bal 18 28 64.3 48 50 96.0
  A. Vinatieri 2014 Ind 30 31 96.8 50 50 100.0
  L. Michaels 1965 Bal 17 28 60.7 48 48 100.0
  L. Michaels 1967 Bal 20 37 54.1 46 48 95.8
  A. Vinatieri 2018 Ind 23 27 85.2 44 47 93.6
  S. Mike-Mayer 1980 Bal 12 23 52.2 43 46 93.5
  M. Vanderjagt 2003 Ind 37 37 100.0 46 46 100.0
  M. Vanderjagt 2000 Ind 25 27 92.6 46 46 100.0
  A. Vinatieri 2016 Ind 27 31 87.1 44 44 100.0
  M. Vanderjagt 1999 Ind 34 38 89.5 43 43 100.0
  A. Vinatieri 2008 Ind 20 25 80.0 43 43 100.0
  M. Vanderjagt 2001 Ind 28 34 82.4 41 42 97.6
  D. Biasucci 1988 Ind 25 32 78.1 39 40 97.5
  R. Allegre 1985 Ind 16 26 61.5 36 39 92.3
  J. O'Brien 1970 Bal 19 34 55.9 36 38 94.7
  A. Vinatieri 2006 Ind 25 28 89.3 38 38 100.0
  D. Biasucci 1994 Ind 16 24 66.7 37 37 100.0
  S. Myhra 1960 Bal 9 19 47.4 35 37 94.6
  A. Vinatieri 2012 Ind 26 33 78.8 37 37 100.0
  L. Michaels 1966 Bal 21 39 53.8 35 36 97.2
  J. O'Brien 1971 Bal 20 29 69.0 35 36 97.2
  T. Linhart 1977 Bal 17 26 65.4 32 35 91.4
  J. Martin 1963 Bal 24 39 61.5 32 35 91.4
  A. Vinatieri 2015 Ind 25 27 92.6 32 35 91.4
  L. Michaels 1969 Bal 14 31 45.2 33 34 97.1
  S. Myhra 1961 Bal 21 39 53.8 33 34 97.1
  M. Vanderjagt 2002 Ind 23 31 74.2 34 34 100.0
  A. Vinatieri 2013 Ind 35 40 87.5 34 34 100.0
  D. Biasucci 1990 Ind 17 24 70.8 32 33 97.0
  M. Stover 2009 Ind 9 11 81.8 33 33 100.0
  M. Wood 1981 Bal 10 18 55.6 29 33 87.9
  D. Biasucci 1989 Ind 21 27 77.8 31 32 96.9
  T. Linhart 1978 Bal 8 17 47.1 27 31 87.1
  S. Mike-Mayer 1979 Bal 11 20 55.0 28 29 96.6
  D. Bielski 1962 Bal 11 25 44.0 25 28 89.3
  A. Vinatieri 2019 Ind 17 25 68.0 22 28 78.6
  D. Biasucci 1986 Ind 13 25 52.0 26 27 96.3
  C. Blanchard 1996 Ind 36 40 90.0 27 27 100.0
  T. Feamster 1956 Bal 0 3 0.0 24 26 92.3
  B. Rechichar 1955 Bal 10 24 41.7 25 26 96.2
  C. Blanchard 1995 Ind 19 24 79.2 25 25 100.0