Indianapolis Colts Career Scoring Leaders

Ranked by Total Points

The following are the Indianapolis Colts career scoring leaders ranked by total points. Included are player stats for the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) from 1984-2020, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) from 1953-1983, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) in 1950 and the Baltimore Colts (AAFC) from 1947-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Adam Vinatieri is the Indianapolis Colts career leader in points scored with 1,515.

Players active with the Indianapolis Colts during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

      Scoring
Player Gms TD FG PAT 2Pt Pts
1. A. Vinatieri 205 0 336 507 0 1,515
2. M. Vanderjagt 125 0 217 344 0 995
3. D. Biasucci 155 0 176 255 0 783
4. M. Harrison 190 128 0 0 5 778
5. L. Moore 143 113 0 0 0 678
6. L. Michaels 84 0 107 263 0 586
7. R. Wayne 211 82 0 0 3 498
8. E. James 96 75 0 0 4 458
9. R. Berry 154 68 0 0 0 408
10. T. Linhart 75 0 70 184 0 394
11. D. McCauley 156 58 0 0 0 348
12. T. Matte 142 57 0 0 0 342
13. C. Blanchard 44 0 87 73 0 334
14. S. Myhra 62 0 44 180 0 312
15. M. Faulk 77 51 0 0 0 306
16. J. Orr 113 50 0 0 0 300
17. J. Addai 78 48 0 0 1 290
18. T. Hilton 118 46 0 0 1 278
19. D. Clark 115 46 0 0 0 276
20. A. Ameche 70 44 0 0 0 264
21. J. O'Brien 42 2 52 95 0 263
22. L. Mitchell 81 41 0 0 0 246
23. R. Allegre 44 0 57 72 0 243
24. J. Mutscheller 95 40 0 0 0 240
25. J. Mackey 126 38 0 0 0 228
26. M. Pollard 146 35 0 0 5 220
27. E. Dickerson 61 35 0 0 0 210
28. C. Dickey 70 34 0 0 0 204
29. D. Rhodes 89 31 0 0 1 188
30. R. Carr 102 29 0 0 0 174
31. A. Bentley 88 28 0 0 0 168
  B. Brooks 106 28 0 0 0 168
33. B. Rechichar 79 4 28 56 0 164
34. R. McMillan 88 26 0 0 0 156
35. J. Hill 102 25 0 0 0 150
36. R. Butler 79 24 0 0 0 144
  G. Doughty 103 24 0 0 0 144
  W. Richardson 99 24 0 0 0 144
39. S. Mike-Mayer 29 0 23 71 0 140
40. M. Mack 40 22 0 0 3 138
41. A. Hawkins 110 20 0 0 0 120
42. D. Allen 57 19 0 0 1 116
  D. Brown 66 19 0 0 1 116
44. F. Gore 48 19 0 0 0 114
  T. Mitchell 77 19 0 0 0 114
46. K. Dilger 109 18 0 0 2 112
47. J. Doyle 100 18 0 0 0 108
  C. Fleener 60 17 0 0 3 108
  D. Moncrief 53 18 0 0 0 108
50. J. Martin 14 0 24 32 0 104