Indianapolis Colts Career Punt Return Leaders

Ranked by Punt Returns

The following are the Indianapolis Colts career punt return leaders ranked by punt returns. Included are player stats for the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) from 1984-2020, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) from 1953-1983, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) in 1950 and the Baltimore Colts (AAFC) from 1947-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Clarence Verdin is the Indianapolis Colts career leader in punt returns with 155.

Players active with the Indianapolis Colts during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

      Punt Returns
Player Gms Num Yds Avg Lg TD
1. C. Verdin 95 155 1,537 9.9 84t 4
2. T. Wilkins 59 119 1,065 8.9 82t 3
3. C. Taseff 91 112 826 7.4 90t 2
4. H. Stevens 38 109 1,012 9.3 53 0
5. A. Haymond 45 108 911 8.4 64 0
6. R. Volk 123 84 548 6.5 24 0
7. N. Glasgow 128 79 651 8.2 75t 1
8. T. Walters 52 74 587 7.9 34 0
9. B. Rechichar 79 71 253 3.6 24 0
10. J. Logan 140 63 577 9.2 43t 1
11. B. Laird 141 60 405 6.8 42 0
  C. Rogers 53 60 551 9.2 51 0
13. R. Martin 23 57 552 9.7 70t 1
14. L. Anderson 30 55 374 6.8 28 0
15. A. Hawkins 110 52 358 6.9 50 0
16. T. Hilton 118 49 482 9.8 75t 1
17. G. Whalen 33 46 376 8.2 51 0
18. Q. Bray 24 45 314 7.0 33 0
19. B. Brooks 106 43 292 6.8 18 0
20. D. Brewer 16 42 339 8.1 75t 1
  T. Rushing 35 42 382 9.1 90t 1
22. J. Sample 35 36 230 6.4 26 0
23. R. Gardin 14 30 405 13.5 80t 1
24. R. Buchanan 61 28 314 11.2 82 0
25. W. Harris 56 25 275 11.0 39 0
  M. Johnson 32 25 143 5.7 17 0
27. B. Stablein 47 23 189 8.2 30 0
28. B. Boyd 121 21 196 9.3 46 0
  B. Young 31 21 69 3.3 16 0
30. A. Bailey 64 20 195 9.8 33 0
  M. Harrison 190 20 189 9.4 31 0
  B. Pyatt 16 20 157 7.8 21 0
33. J. Cribbs 6 19 125 6.6 18 0
34. P. Garcon 58 17 49 2.9 20 0
  B. White 20 17 102 6.0 18 0
36. T. Berra 14 16 114 7.1 14 0
  T. Brown 11 16 125 7.8 25 0
  K. Ratliff 14 16 89 5.6 19 0
39. G. Taliaferro 22 15 65 4.3 18 0
40. L. Moore 143 14 56 4.0 15 0
  R. Porter 14 14 104 7.4 50 0
42. B. Bronson 9 13 79 6.1 32 0
  S. Havrilak 69 13 56 4.3 13 0
  N. Jacquet 5 13 96 7.4 17 0
45. L. Blackwood 57 12 23 1.9 10 0
  T. Poole 45 12 107 8.9 16 0
  H. Rich 0 12 276 23.0 86 1
48. T. Curtis 24 10 17 1.7 10 0
  D. Shula 16 10 50 5.0 11 0
  B. Turner 14 10 95 9.5 43 0