Indianapolis Colts Career Punting Leaders

Ranked by Punting Gross Average

The following are the Indianapolis Colts career punting leaders ranked by punting gross average. Included are player stats for the Indianapolis Colts (NFL) from 1984-2020, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) from 1953-1983, the Baltimore Colts (NFL) in 1950 and the Baltimore Colts (AAFC) from 1947-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Pat McAfee is the Indianapolis Colts career leader in gross punting average with 46.4.

Players active with the Indianapolis Colts during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

Leaders based on 250 punts

      Punting
Player Gms Num Yds Avg Lg TB In20 Blk Net
1. P. McAfee 127 575 26,669 46.4 74 49 193 4 39.8
2. C. Gardocki 64 277 12,403 44.8 72 25 80 0 36.5
3. R. Stark 197 985 43,162 43.8 72 111 224 7 35.5
4. H. Smith 160 577 25,038 43.4 69 61 193 5 35.2
5. D. Lee 184 838 34,019 40.6 76 21 57 11 38.2