Cleveland Browns Career Punt Return Leaders

Ranked by Punt Return Yards

The following are the Cleveland Browns career punt return leaders ranked by punt return yards. Included are player stats for the Cleveland Browns (NFL) from 1999-2020, the Cleveland Browns (NFL) from 1950-1995 and the Cleveland Browns (AAFC) from 1946-1949. Only stats for Regular Season Games have been included. Joshua Cribbs is the Cleveland Browns career leader in punt return yards with 2,154.

Players active with the Cleveland Browns during the 2019 NFL season are listed in bold.

      Punt Returns
Player Gms Num Yds Avg Lg TD
1. J. Cribbs 124 195 2,154 11.0 84t 3
2. D. Northcutt 100 202 2,149 10.6 87t 3
3. G. McNeil 60 161 1,545 9.6 84t 1
4. E. Metcalf 88 127 1,341 10.6 92t 5
5. L. Kelly 136 94 990 10.5 74 3
6. D. Hall 64 111 901 8.1 47 0
7. T. Benjamin 54 68 857 12.6 93t 3
8. G. Pruitt 118 56 659 11.8 72 0
9. B. Mitchell 50 54 607 11.2 78t 3
10. K. Konz 84 68 556 8.2 65t 1
11. K. Wright 33 78 467 6.0 42 0
12. B. Brennan 117 55 435 7.9 37t 1
13. J. Peppers 29 55 399 7.3 33 0
14. D. Paul 59 48 383 8.0 60t 1
15. K. Carpenter 43 34 370 10.9 54t 1
16. B. Reynolds 36 67 363 5.4 39 0
17. W. Roberts 42 39 336 8.6 51 0
18. J. Shofner 76 46 308 6.7 36 0
19. R. Woolsey 14 32 290 9.1 44 0
20. T. Darden 128 45 285 6.3 45 0
21. K. Johnson 73 33 245 7.4 24 0
22. B. Davis 74 27 240 8.9 52t 1
23. C. Weathers 57 30 228 7.6 16 0
24. R. Renfro 142 40 225 5.6 34 0
25. S. Holden 48 33 224 6.8 38 0
26. M. Carrier 32 15 204 13.6 60 1
27. D. Phelps 17 19 192 10.1 54t 1
28. R. Morrison 54 26 182 7.0 34 0
29. D. Walker 36 28 177 6.3 14 0
30. W. Sumner 76 18 172 9.6 38 0
31. R. Feacher 122 15 157 10.5 49 0
32. J. Poyer 45 17 144 8.5 38 0
33. J. Shorter 20 7 134 19.1 52 0
34. D. Johnson 64 20 129 6.5 18 0
35. D. Moselle 11 7 126 18.0 48 0
36. D. Alexander 28 9 122 13.6 69t 1
37. C. Hanulak 24 38 121 3.2 43 0
  C. Montgomery 4 17 121 7.1 17 0
39. W. Slaughter 84 18 114 6.3 17 0
40. E. Green 89 11 110 10.0 55 0
41. D. Hilliard 25 15 107 7.1 18 0
42. T. Wilson 3 10 101 10.1 17 0
43. B. Majors 9 16 96 6.0 41 0
44. C. Leigh 27 19 94 4.9 29 0
45. K. McCardell 37 13 93 7.2 17 0
46. K. Gorgal 35 5 83 16.6 33 0
47. S. Adams 10 13 81 6.2 25 0
48. D. Harris 11 9 73 8.1 13 0
49. W. Miller 20 15 69 4.6 23 0
50. M. Alford 3 8 68 8.5 17 0